Guide · Audio formats
MP3, M4A, FLAC or WAV? Audio quality, explained simply
Every song file is a trade-off between sound and size. Here is what the numbers on a file really mean, which formats count as low, standard, high and studio quality, and why a 256 kbps M4A sounds better than a 256 kbps MP3.
The short version
There are two families of audio files. Lossless files (WAV, FLAC) keep every bit of the original recording. Lossy files (MP3, M4A, Opus) throw away the parts of the sound your ear is least likely to notice, so the file gets 5 to 10 times smaller.
For lossy files, the number that matters most is the bitrate, measured in kbps (kilobits per second): how much data describes each second of music. More data means fewer details thrown away. But the bitrate is only half the story, because a newer, smarter format gets more sound out of the same data. That is why M4A at 256 kbps is very high quality, a level MP3 only reaches at 320 kbps.
The four quality levels
A simple scale we use across MixSongs. Bitrates are for stereo music.
-
Low
★★★★★ MP3 below 128 kbps, AAC below 96 kbps, Opus below 64 kbps. Fine for speech and a phone speaker. On headphones, cymbals sound “swishy” and the highs are cut off.
-
Standard
★★★★★ MP3 128 to 192 kbps, M4A (AAC) 128 kbps, Opus 96 to 128 kbps. What most people hear every day. Good on earbuds, small flaws on a good system.
-
High
★★★★★ MP3 256 to 320 kbps, M4A (AAC) 192 to 320 kbps, Opus 160 kbps and up. For almost every listener, in blind tests, indistinguishable from the original. M4A 256 kbps is the format Apple sells music in.
-
Studio (lossless)
★★★★★ WAV and FLAC. Nothing is thrown away: 16-bit / 44.1 kHz is CD quality, 24-bit up to 96 kHz is “hi-res”, the format studios mix and master in.
Three numbers on every audio file
Sample rate (kHz) is how many times per second the sound wave is measured. CDs use 44.1 kHz (44,100 measurements a second), video and most phones use 48 kHz. Human hearing tops out around 20 kHz, and a sample rate captures frequencies up to half its value, so 44.1 kHz already covers everything we can hear. 96 kHz gives engineers extra headroom for heavy processing.
Bit depth (16 or 24 bit) is how precisely each measurement is stored. It decides the gap between the quietest and loudest sound the file can hold: about 96 dB for 16-bit, 144 dB for 24-bit. 16-bit is plenty for listening; 24-bit matters while recording and mixing, where you keep turning levels up and down.
Bitrate (kbps) is the amount of data per second. For uncompressed audio it is simply the math: 44,100 × 16 bit × 2 channels = 1,411 kbps for CD quality. An MP3 at 128 kbps is about 11 times less data. That gap is what lossy compression fills by cleverly deciding what to throw away.
WAV: the raw recording
WAV is the audio, sample by sample, with no compression at all. It is what recording software writes and what every editor can open. Nothing is lost and nothing needs decoding, which makes it the safest format for editing.
The price is size: about 10 MB per minute at CD quality, and over 30 MB per minute at 24-bit / 96 kHz. WAV also carries very little information about the song (title, artist, cover art are poorly supported).
FLAC: WAV, zipped
FLAC (Free Lossless Audio Codec) packs the same audio the way a ZIP file packs a document: it gets 40 to 60% smaller, and when you play it, every single sample comes back exactly as it was. A FLAC and a WAV of the same recording are bit-for-bit identical in sound.
FLAC is open and free, supports full tags and cover art, and is the format of lossless streaming (Tidal, Amazon Music, Qobuz and Spotify Lossless). If you want to keep a mix at full quality without eating your disk, FLAC is the right choice.
MP3: the format that changed music
MP3 was finished in the early 1990s at Germany’s Fraunhofer Institute and made music small enough for the internet. It uses a model of human hearing (psychoacoustics): a loud sound hides quieter sounds near it in pitch, and very high frequencies are hard to hear, so those details get dropped.
MP3 is supported by literally everything, which is its biggest strength. Its weaknesses come from its age. At 128 kbps encoders usually cut everything above about 16 kHz, and sharp sounds like hi-hats and hand claps can get a smeared “pre-echo”. 320 kbps is the highest bitrate MP3 allows, and at that point it sounds very good.
M4A / MP4 (AAC): the successor to MP3
AAC (Advanced Audio Coding) was designed by the same industry group as MP3 (MPEG, with Fraunhofer, Dolby, Sony and AT&T) to be its replacement. It splits sound into frequencies more precisely, switches faster between short and long blocks for sharp attacks, and wastes fewer bits. The result: at the same bitrate, AAC sounds noticeably better than MP3.
Roughly speaking, AAC at 128 kbps is as good as MP3 at around 160 to 192 kbps, and AAC at 256 kbps is a very high level: in listening tests, almost no one can tell it from the CD. It is the standard of the iTunes Store and Apple Music, and YouTube’s AAC streams use it too.
About the names: .m4a and .mp4 are the same container (MPEG-4). An .mp4 file usually carries video plus AAC sound, and .m4a is the audio-only version. When we say “MP4 audio” or “M4A”, we mean AAC inside that container.
Format by format
Sizes are for a 3-minute stereo song.
| Format | Type | Typical bitrate | 3-min song | Quality |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| WAV 24-bit / 96 kHz | Lossless | 4,608 kbps | ≈ 104 MB | ★★★★★ Studio, hi-res |
| WAV 16-bit / 44.1 kHz | Lossless | 1,411 kbps | ≈ 32 MB | ★★★★★ Studio (CD) |
| FLAC 16-bit / 44.1 kHz | Lossless | ≈ 700–1,000 kbps | ≈ 15–22 MB | ★★★★★ Studio (CD) |
| M4A (AAC) 256 kbps | Lossy | 256 kbps | ≈ 5.8 MB | ★★★★★ High |
| MP3 320 kbps | Lossy | 320 kbps | ≈ 7.2 MB | ★★★★★ High |
| Opus 160 kbps | Lossy | 160 kbps | ≈ 3.6 MB | ★★★★★ High |
| MP3 192 kbps | Lossy | 192 kbps | ≈ 4.3 MB | ★★★★★ Standard |
| MP3 128 kbps | Lossy | 128 kbps | ≈ 2.9 MB | ★★★★★ Standard |
| MP3 96 kbps | Lossy | 96 kbps | ≈ 2.2 MB | ★★★★★ Low |
Same bitrate, different sound
Why the format matters as much as the number: MP3 and AAC at the same bitrate, side by side.
| Bitrate | MP3 | M4A (AAC) |
|---|---|---|
| 96 kbps | ★★★★★ Low, audible artifacts | ★★★★★ OK on earbuds |
| 128 kbps | ★★★★★ Standard | ★★★★★ Good, like MP3 ≈ 160–192 |
| 192 kbps | ★★★★★ Good | ★★★★★ Very good |
| 256 kbps | ★★★★★ Very good | ★★★★★ Excellent, near-transparent |
| 320 kbps | ★★★★★ Excellent, MP3’s maximum | ★★★★★ Excellent |
Opus: the newest of them all
Opus is an open, royalty-free codec standardized in 2012. It is the most efficient format in wide use: around 128 kbps it already sounds excellent for music, and it powers WhatsApp calls, Discord, Zoom and most of YouTube. MixSongs opens Opus files, and we explain where you hear it every day in our guide to Spotify and YouTube audio quality.
The catch: Opus is not supported everywhere. It is not accepted when you send a song through WhatsApp, and CD players and most car stereos cannot play it. So even though it is efficient and sounds great, we do not recommend exporting your mix as Opus. For sharing and playing anywhere, M4A or MP3 are the safer choice.
One rule that saves a lot of confusion
Converting a file can never add back quality that was thrown away. An MP3 at 128 kbps saved as a 320 kbps MP3, or as a FLAC, gets bigger but sounds exactly the same (or slightly worse, if it is re-encoded to another lossy format). Quality is set by the weakest step in the chain.
So: keep your sources as high quality as you can get, edit in lossless, and choose the final format at the end, by where the file is going.
What MixSongs opens and exports
MixSongs opens MP3, WAV, FLAC, M4A / MP4 (AAC), AAC, OGG, Opus, WebM and AIFF. Mixing happens in high precision inside your browser, and the format is chosen only when you export:
- Free: MP3 at 128 or 192 kbps (standard quality), great for sharing and for phones.
- Pro export: MP3 at 256 or 320 kbps, M4A (AAC) up to 320 kbps, and lossless WAV and FLAC in 16 or 24-bit, at up to 96 kHz.
- Our advice: M4A 256 kbps for listening and sharing at high quality, FLAC to keep a master copy, WAV when the file goes into another editor.
Audio format questions
Is FLAC better than WAV?
They sound identical: both are lossless. FLAC is about half the size and stores song info and cover art. WAV is simpler and opens in every editor, which is why studios still pass WAVs around.
Is 320 kbps MP3 as good as FLAC?
For most people on most equipment, in a blind test, yes. Trained listeners on good systems can sometimes pick out tricky passages. FLAC is still the better choice for archiving and editing, because it never loses anything.
Why does M4A sound better than MP3 at the same bitrate?
AAC, the codec inside M4A, is the more advanced successor to MP3. It has finer frequency resolution, handles sharp attacks better and spends its bits more wisely, so it needs less data for the same sound.
Should I convert my MP3s to FLAC?
No. You will get files three to five times bigger with exactly the same sound. Lossless only helps when the source was lossless.
Do I need 24-bit / 96 kHz?
For listening, CD quality (16-bit / 44.1 kHz) already covers the full range of human hearing. 24-bit and higher sample rates are useful while producing, where audio is processed many times over.
What is the difference between M4A and MP4?
They are the same container format. MP4 usually means video with sound, M4A means audio only. Inside, the music is normally encoded with AAC.
Keep reading
Mix in high quality, export in the format you need
Free MP3 export, lossless WAV and FLAC with Pro.
Open MixSongs